top of page

Florida's Living Will Is Narrow. More Checkboxes Won't Fix It.

Writer: Meghan Maher, MPH
Meghan Maher, MPH
Nov 4
4 min read

A row of boxes. A pen. A signature line.


Most people come to advance care planning expecting a form, and most assume the more they fill in, the safer they'll be. Check enough boxes and no one will have to guess. Spell everything out and nothing can go wrong.

It's an understandable hope. It just isn't how this works.

Sunlit table with a Florida living will, pen, coffee mug, and flowers by a window, creating a calm, reflective mood.

Last month, I asked newsletter readers to name a health care surrogate, and I promised I'd come back to the living will on its own. This is that piece.


Florida's statutory living will covers three situations: a terminal condition, an end-stage condition, or a persistent vegetative state. In those situations, it directs that life-prolonging procedures be withheld or withdrawn when they would only prolong the process of dying. Then there is one optional line for additional instructions. Almost no one writes anything on it.


It doesn't ask what you'd want if a treatment might actually work. It doesn't ask whether you'd try something for a while and then stop. It doesn't ask where you want to be, or who you want in the room.


The form is narrow by design, and what it covers matters. But Florida doesn’t require you to use it. The law offers it as a model, not a mandate. You are allowed to say more.


So the natural instinct is to add boxes.


Some tools do exactly that. Compassion & Choices offers an end-of-life planning guide and toolkit, which includes an addendum that lists ten life-sustaining treatments one at a time — antibiotics, dialysis, a ventilator, artificial nutrition and hydration among them — and asks you to mark each one yes, no, or trial period. That third column is the gem. It leaves room for what no one can know in advance: whether a treatment will work.


Here is the limit of precision. You check "no ventilator" picturing yourself in a hospital bed with no chance of waking up. Then one winter you're 58 with severe pneumonia, and four days on a ventilator would bring you all the way back. The box you checked to protect yourself is now standing between you and recovery.


What you value hasn't changed. The situation has. None of us can picture every possible situation we might find ourselves in.


Precision is not protection.


This isn't only a doula's view. In a recent issue of the NAEPC Journal of Estate & Tax Planning, Kim Heyman, who spent more than twenty years as a trusts-and-estates attorney, made the same case to her own colleagues. She argues that procedure-by-procedure instructions from people who aren't clinicians tend to be too specific to be useful, and that people usually fare better when they name someone they trust and give that person room to decide. PREPARE for Your Care, the free planning program from University of California San Francisco, builds the same idea in: one of its five steps asks how much flexibility you want your decision maker to have.


There's a name for what that person does — substituted judgement. Substituted judgment means deciding as you would have decided — not as they'd choose for themselves, and not by only following a form.


Latitude is a gift to the person you name. It is also a weight.


A checklist does one thing well. It lets your person say, "I'm just doing what she wrote down." Take the checklist away, and you've handed them something heavier than a form. You've handed them the decision.


In my work as an end-of-life doula, I've stood in hospital hallways with adult children who have every document in order and still don't have the answer. The question they ask isn't "What does the form say?" It's "Is this what Mom would want?" When they don't know, the not-knowing stays with them long after the decision is made.


Two things can be true. Your person needs permission to make the call. They also need to know you well enough to make it.


What makes latitude bearable isn't more boxes. It's a few honest sentences about what matters to you.


Instead of "no ventilator.", something like:

I'll accept a hard stretch if there's a real chance I come back to myself. I don't want to keep going if I can no longer recognize the people I love. Being home matters more to me than being in a hospital. If you have to choose, choose comfort.


The strongest case in Kim Heyman's article sits in a footnote. Her father once told her older siblings that he wasn't afraid of death. When the time came to decide about hospice, that one sentence made an impossible moment a little easier to carry. No checkbox would have done that.


Specificity still has a place. If you have a true non-negotiable — a treatment you'd refuse whatever the odds, or one you'd always want tried — write it down plainly.


Here's what that could look like in practice.


Choose your surrogate for steadiness and judgement, not because they're next in line. Write a few sentences about what makes a life worth living for you, and what would make a treatment feel like too much. Then say them out loud to the person you named, and ask the question: do you feel ready to decide for me?


If you need more room than Florida's form gives you, an elder law attorney or a free tool like PREPARE can help you put it in a document that still meets Florida's signing requirements.


A row of boxes can't stand in that hospital hallway with your person. A few sentences in your own words can.


That one optional line on Florida's form, the one almost nobody fills in, may be the most important space on the page.

 
 
bottom of page